When it comes to Tinto Brass, opinions often vary widely across his filmography, but if we look at the ratings, there’s a clear standout. Tinto Brass’s highest rated movie is undoubtedly Caligula: The Ultimate Cut (2023), which has gained notable acclaim and appreciation in recent years. Fans and critics alike have praised this reimagined version for its refined storytelling and improved coherence. On the other hand, Tinto Brass’s lowest rated film remains the original Caligula (1979), which, despite its cult following, received significant criticism upon release. While Tinto Brass brought a unique vision to the project, many felt the earlier version was overly controversial without enough substance. So, when comparing the two, it’s clear that Tinto Brass’s later work with the 2023 cut has been much more favorably received. Overall, Tinto Brass continues to be a polarizing yet influential figure in cinema, especially when revisiting bold projects like these.