R.J. Cutler has long been a major force in the world of documentaries, but his journey began not behind the camera capturing real-life stories, but in the theater. Yes, R.J. Cutler actually started out directing stage productions before making the shift to film and television—where he would eventually become widely recognized for his insightful storytelling. Born in 1961, R.J. Cutler grew up in Great Neck, New York, and went on to graduate from Harvard University in 1984. Early in his career, when the New York Drama League launched its Director Apprenticeship Program, R.J. Cutler was the very first director selected—a clear sign of his emerging talent.
During this time, he worked with the American Repertory Theater and served as an assistant director on Stephen Sondheim’s “Into the Woods” during its Broadway debut in 1986. Among the plays R.J. Cutler directed were notable works like “Right Behind the Flag” (1988), featuring a young Kevin Spacey, “Emerald City” (1987), and the acclaimed musical “The Secret Garden” (1991). But as impactful as his theater work was, it was just the beginning.
In the early ‘90s, R.J. Cutler transitioned into documentary filmmaking, marking a pivotal moment in his career. His breakthrough came with “The War Room” (1993), a gripping behind-the-scenes look at Bill Clinton’s presidential campaign. Though produced by R.J. Cutler and co-directed by documentary legends D.A. Pennebaker and Chris Hegedus, the project bore Cutler’s distinct vision and earned widespread acclaim. Its success led to a follow-up over a decade later—”The Return of the War Room” (2008)—in which R.J. Cutler revisited the original team and reflected on the impact of their work.
Not one to rest on his laurels, R.J. Cutler continued exploring political narratives with “A Perfect Candidate” (1996), a compelling portrait of Oliver North’s Senate run. He also ventured into observational documentary series with “American High” (Fox, 2000), which followed the lives of teenagers in a suburban high school. While critics praised the show’s authenticity, Fox canceled it after only four episodes due to low ratings. Fortunately, PBS picked it up—and under R.J. Cutler’s guidance—it went on to win the very first Emmy Award for Outstanding Reality Program.
Always pushing boundaries, R.J. Cutler expanded his focus with projects like “Freshman Diaries” (Showtime, 2003), which chronicled college life, and “The Residents” (Discovery Health Channel, 2003), offering an intimate look at medical interns at UCLA. He also served as a producer on the innovative FX series “30 Days” (2005–2008), where host Morgan Spurlock immersed himself in different social environments for a month at a time—an approach that reflected R.J. Cutler’s interest in experiential storytelling.
Over the years, R.J. Cutler built an impressive portfolio of producing credits, including “Shays’ Rebellion: America’s First Civil War” (2005), the critically acclaimed “Thin” (2006) about eating disorders, and “Hick Town” (2009), a profile of John Hickenlooper, who later became governor of Colorado. One of his most talked-about films was “The September Issue” (2009), a revealing look at Vogue editor Anna Wintour—this word-of-mouth hit further cemented R.J. Cutler’s reputation as a master of character-driven nonfiction.
By 2012, R.J. Cutler had secured a deal with Showtime to develop more documentaries, returning to politics with “The World According to Dick Cheney” (2013). Around the same time, he founded his own production company, Actual Reality Pictures, through which he created a range of programs, including “Military Diaries” (VH1, 2002) and the popular home renovation series “Flip That House” (TLC, 2005–2008).
Expanding beyond documentaries, R.J. Cutler made his mark in feature films with “If I Stay” (2014), a moving supernatural drama starring Chloë Grace Moretz as a teenager in a coma, torn between life and death. The film showcased R.J. Cutler’s ability to handle emotional depth with sensitivity and grace. Meanwhile, he served as executive producer on the hit ABC drama “Nashville” (2012– ), further demonstrating his versatility across genres.
Throughout his career, R.J. Cutler has remained a consistent innovator—whether telling true stories or shaping fictional narratives. From theater stages to presidential campaigns, from high school hallways to hospital wards, R.J. Cutler’s body of work reflects a deep curiosity about people and the worlds they inhabit.
When it comes to R.J. Cutler’s body of work, there’s a clear standout in terms of critical reception. R.J. Cutler’s highest rated film to date is The Disappearance of Shere Hite (2023), which has been widely praised for its compelling storytelling and emotional depth. Over the years, R.J. Cutler has built a strong reputation in documentary filmmaking, and this particular project really showcases his strengths as a director. On the other end of the spectrum, R.J. Cutler’s lowest rated release is If I Stay (2014), a drama that, while emotionally driven, didn’t resonate as strongly with critics or audiences. It’s interesting to see how R.J. Cutler’s career spans different genres and formats, yet his most impactful work remains rooted in powerful real-life narratives. Still, R.J. Cutler continues to be a respected figure in the industry, consistently delivering projects that spark conversation.