Edgar Redmond is one of the more memorable recurring characters in Black Butler (Kuroshitsuji), a dark and captivating anime and manga series created by Yana Toboso. As part of the enigmatic Noah’s Ark Circus, Edgar stands out not only for his flamboyant presence but also for the depth of his character arc. Known within the circus as the “Crimson Red Wild,” he performs alongside his twin brother, Edward, and together they form a dynamic duo that leaves a lasting impression on both audiences and viewers alike.

Right from the start, Edgar Redmond is introduced as a key member of the traveling circus troupe, which features a range of unusual and mesmerizing acts—everything from the Flying Trapeze to the Human Cannonball. Edgar and Edward are specifically involved in the “Snake Charmer” performance, showcasing their coordination, agility, and theatrical flair. Edgar himself has a bold and dramatic personality, often dressed in vibrant, eccentric outfits that mirror his larger-than-life stage persona. It’s hard not to notice Edgar Redmond when he steps into a scene—he commands attention.

But as the story unfolds, we begin to see that there’s much more beneath the surface. Edgar Redmond’s past is anything but glamorous. In fact, it’s deeply tragic. He and his brother were among a group of children subjected to cruel and inhumane experiments conducted by a deranged scientist. These horrific experiences granted them unique abilities, but at a terrible cost—their parents’ lives. This trauma becomes the driving force behind Edgar’s actions throughout the series. His burning desire for revenge leads him to align with the series’ mysterious antagonist, Undertaker, making him a morally complex figure.

Even though Edgar Redmond makes choices that place him on the wrong side of justice, his loyalty to his twin brother remains unwavering. No matter the situation, the two brothers operate as a unit, relying on each other’s strengths. Edgar’s acrobatic prowess combined with his sharp mind makes him a formidable asset to the Noah’s Ark Circus. Over time, his evolution from a mere performer to a determined avenger adds layers to his character, making Edgar Redmond one of the more intriguing figures in Black Butler.

When we take a closer look at Edgar Redmond’s behavior and decision-making patterns, certain psychological insights emerge. Based on his traits, it’s reasonable to classify him as an ESTJ—Extroverted, Sensing, Thinking, Judging. Edgar Redmond exudes confidence and takes charge whenever necessary, showing natural leadership qualities. He’s goal-driven, practical, and highly organized, especially when coordinating plans or managing others. His approach is always structured, favoring logic over emotion, which allows him to remain calm and rational even under pressure.

Moreover, Edgar Redmond thrives in action-oriented environments. His extroverted energy is evident in how he interacts with allies and enemies alike, often taking the lead in confrontations. He’s constantly strategizing, planning his next move with precision—clear signs of a Judging personality type. The way he speaks—direct, authoritative, and sometimes harsh—reflects a Thinking preference, where efficiency and results outweigh emotional considerations. And let’s be honest, Edgar Redmond isn’t one to embrace uncertainty or untested ideas. His reliance on order and control highlights a deep need for stability, which is typical of ESTJs.

Beyond the MBTI framework, Edgar Redmond also fits the profile of an Enneagram Type 8: The Challenger. This type is defined by a powerful drive to be in control, to protect what’s theirs, and to resist vulnerability at all costs. Edgar Redmond embodies this perfectly. He refuses to be a victim, instead choosing to wield power and influence to shape his own destiny. Whether it’s confronting authority or standing up for those he cares about, he does so with fearless determination.

That said, Type 8s aren’t without their flaws—and Edgar Redmond is no exception. His tendency toward aggression and intimidation reveals the darker side of his personality. When challenged or threatened, he doesn’t hesitate to respond with force. Yet, this same intensity fuels his protective instincts. Despite his alliance with antagonistic forces, Edgar Redmond’s actions are ultimately rooted in a sense of justice—for his family, for his brother, and for the life that was stolen from them.

In the end, Edgar Redmond is far more than just a circus performer or a villainous side character. His journey through pain, vengeance, and loyalty makes him a compelling figure in Black Butler. Whether you’re analyzing him through the lens of personality typology or simply watching his story unfold, Edgar Redmond leaves a strong impression. So, while interpretations may vary, one thing is clear: Edgar Redmond is a character whose strength, complexity, and fierce devotion make him unforgettable.