When it comes to Donald Randolph’s career highlights, one film really stands out—Cowboy from 1958. That particular movie tends to be regarded as Donald Randolph’s highest rated film, earning solid praise over the years. On the flip side, not every project hit the mark; for instance, The Silver Chalice (1954) didn’t receive the same level of acclaim and is often cited as Donald Randolph’s lowest rated movie. While opinions may vary, these two titles represent the upper and lower ends of his filmography in terms of critical reception. Still, Donald Randolph’s contributions across different roles remain noteworthy throughout his time in the industry.