When it comes to Cathy Downs’s filmography, one standout performance definitely shines brighter than the rest—her highest rated movie is My Darling Clementine from 1946. This classic Western, directed by John Ford, really showcases Cathy Downs at her best, delivering a memorable and heartfelt performance that critics and audiences alike have praised over the years. On the other hand, among the films she appeared in, The Amazing Colossal Man (1957) tends to receive the lowest ratings. While it has gained some cult status over time for its sci-fi camp value, it doesn’t quite match the acclaim of her earlier work. So, when you look at Cathy Downs’s career overall, there’s a clear contrast between these two titles—one representing a high point and the other, well, not so much. Still, both roles contribute to the legacy of Cathy Downs in their own unique way.