So, when we look at Ann McCrea’s career highlights, it’s clear that her highest rated film by far is Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter? from 1957. That movie really stands out in her body of work and seems to be the one where Ann McCrea truly shined. On the other hand, if we consider critical reception or audience scores, Ann McCrea’s lowest rated project would have to be The War Wagon, released a decade later in 1967. While both films are part of her legacy, there’s definitely a noticeable difference in how they were received. Ann McCrea clearly made a stronger impact with her earlier performance, and fans often point to that era as the peak of her on-screen presence. Ann McCrea certainly had her ups and downs, but her role in the 1957 comedy remains her most celebrated to date.